A Super Scary Narwhalloween vs Absent: Which Graphic Novel Wins?
By Books of Wonder | Published: 2026-10-22
Category: Comparisons
Two very different graphic novels for middle grade readers: one a spooky, silly Narwhal and Jelly adventure, the other a poignant story told in verse, prose, and comics. Which fits your reader?
Quick answer
For a lighthearted, laugh-out-loud read, choose A Super Scary Narwhalloween; for a deeper, emotionally resonant story, choose Absent.
Tone and Storytelling Style
A Super Scary Narwhalloween is the eighth book in the blockbuster Narwhal and Jelly graphic novel series. It delivers three new stories filled with silly costumes and Halloween fun, perfect for readers who want pure entertainment.
Absent takes a different approach. It's a mixed-format middle grade novel that blends verse, prose, and comics to tell the story of three boys who skip school. The subject matter—dealing with a parent in jail, responsibility, and finding your own path—is more serious and emotional.
The trade-off is clear: one is a light, quick read; the other is a more substantial story that may prompt thoughtful conversations.
Age and Reading Level Considerations
The Narwhal and Jelly series is generally aimed at younger readers, around ages 6-9, with simple vocabulary and a focus on friendship and humor.
Absent, with its mixed-format narrative and heavier themes, is better suited for older middle grade readers, around ages 10-14, who can handle complex emotions and narrative structures.
Consider the reader's maturity and reading confidence when choosing between the two.
How to choose: trade-offs at a glance
- Mood: Choose A Super Scary Narwhalloween for a silly, upbeat Halloween read. Choose Absent if you want a story that explores real-life challenges.
- Reading level: A Super Scary Narwhalloween suits younger or emerging readers. Absent is better for older middle graders who can handle more complex themes and formats. Match the book to the reader's maturity, not just their age.
- Series vs. standalone: A Super Scary Narwhalloween is part of a beloved series—great if the reader already knows Narwhal and Jelly. Absent is a standalone novel, perfect if they prefer a complete story in one book.
Product facts
- A Super Scary Narwhalloween: In this eighth book of the blockbuster graphic novel series, Narwhal and Jelly celebrate Halloween with three new stories full of spooky and silly costumes. If your reader loves the series, this installment delivers more of the same humor and friendship they already enjoy.
A Super Scary Narwhalloween - Absent: From award-winning author Rex Ogle, this mixed-format middle grade novel tells the story of three boys who skip school, using verse, prose, and comics. The combination of formats keeps the story engaging for reluctant readers while tackling deeper themes.
Absent
Which book fits your reader?
Best for
- Fans of the Narwhal and Jelly series who want a fun Halloween-themed adventure
- Younger readers (ages 6-9) looking for a light, humorous graphic novel
Not for
- Readers seeking a serious, emotionally complex story—choose Absent instead
- Older middle grade readers who may find the Narwhal and Jelly plots too simple
