Back to Blog
Comparisons 2026-11-14 Books of Wonder 0 views

Three Collectible Alice in Wonderland Editions Compared

Three Collectible Alice in Wonderland Editions Compared

A 1915 dramatization, a signed Zwerger first thus, and a Matthews slipcased edition: how to choose between three very different collectible Alices.

Three Alices, Three Different Collecting Goals

These three books share a title but almost nothing else. One is a 1915 stage adaptation with a scarce dust jacket; one is a 1999 picture-book Alice illustrated by Lisbeth Zwerger with a signed bookplate laid in; one is a 2009 Matthews-illustrated edition in a pictorial slipcase. The right choice depends on whether you collect theatrical history, signed illustration, or a display-ready modern illustrated edition.

Because the records describe different formats and editions, compare them on what each actually is rather than on a single ranking. The evidence below is drawn from the catalog entries; where a detail is not stated, treat it as unconfirmed rather than assume it.

Edition by Edition: What Each Copy Actually Is

  • Gerstenberg, 1915: a dramatization, first edition: Alice Gerstenberg's stage adaptation of both Alice's Adventures in Wonderland and Through the Looking Glass, published by A.C. McClurg & Co in 1915. 8vo, [x] 133pp, red cloth stamped in gilt and brown, pictorial endpapers, 6 color plates and numerous two-color illustrations. The catalog calls it scarce in dust jacket.
  • Carroll/Zwerger, 1999: first edition thus, signed bookplate: Lewis Carroll's text illustrated by Lisbeth Zwerger, North-South Books, 1999. 4to, 103pp, color pictorial boards, green endpapers, color illustrations throughout, fine in original pictorial dust jacket, with a bookplate signed by Zwerger laid in.
  • Carroll/Matthews, 2009: first Matthews-illustrated edition, US issue: Lewis Carroll's text illustrated by Rodney Matthews, Templar Books, 2009. 4to, 95pp, color pictorial boards, purple endpapers, color illustrations throughout, fine in original pictorial slipcase with slight bumping to corners.

Condition and Extras That Drive the Decision

  • Alice in Wonderland: Some dampstaining to cloth around edges and spine; spine ends and lower corners a bit rubbed; internally clean and tight, in the original color pictorial dust jacket (dampstained around edges and spine, foxing to front panel, light chipping and wear across upper edge, slightly soiled). The jacket is the scarce part, but it carries visible wear and dampstaining. Buyers who want a clean jacket should weigh that against the rarity of finding one at all.
    Alice in Wonderland
    Alice in Wonderland
  • Alice in Wonderland: A fine copy in original color pictorial dust jacket, with a bookplate signed by the artist, Lisbeth Zwerger, laid in. This is the only one of the three with a signature, and the book itself is described as fine. That combination supports a signed-illustrator collecting focus.
    Alice in Wonderland
    Alice in Wonderland
  • Alice in Wonderland: A fine copy in original color pictorial slipcase (slight bumping to corners). The slipcase protects the book and makes it easy to display, though the corner bumping is a condition note to accept or negotiate around.

Which Collector Should Choose Which

  • Theater and adaptation collectors: Choose the 1915 Gerstenberg dramatization. It is a first edition of a stage adaptation by a playwright associated with Chicago's Little Theatre Movement, and the catalog notes it is scarce in dust jacket. Expect to accept jacket wear as part of the package.
  • Signed and illustrated-book collectors: Choose the 1999 Zwerger first thus. The signed bookplate laid in and the fine book/jacket condition make it the strongest signature-led option among the three.
  • Display and gift-oriented buyers: Choose the 2009 Matthews edition. The pictorial slipcase and color illustrations throughout suit a shelf or gift copy, with the caveat of slight corner bumping on the slipcase.

What the Records Do Not Confirm

The catalog entries do not state print run sizes, exact limitation numbers, or whether the Zwerger and Matthews editions include a particular preface or supplementary essay. They also do not give page-by-page condition reports beyond the notes quoted above. If any of those details matter to your collecting criteria, ask before buying rather than inferring from the edition descriptions.

All three are listed as hardcover in the available variant evidence, so format is not a differentiator here. The meaningful differences are edition type, illustrator, signature, jacket or slipcase, and the condition notes supplied for each copy.

Related Articles

Customer Service
Home
Products
Cart
Profile